Would You Trust a Citizens’ Assembly If It Disagreed With You?
Most people like the idea of giving ordinary citizens more influence — until those citizens…

Most people like the idea of giving ordinary citizens more influence — until those citizens reach a conclusion they dislike.
That is one of the awkward tests facing any alternative to conventional electoral politics.
A study published online by the *European Journal of Political Research* in January 2026 examined public support for deliberative citizens’ assemblies selected through sortition across 15 Western European countries. The researchers found that people who felt less politically competent and those with more anti-elite attitudes were among the groups most supportive of the model.
But there was a complication: support was partly dependent on what people expected the assembly to decide.
In plain English, some people were more enthusiastic about citizen deliberation when they expected it to produce an outcome they favoured.
That is understandable. Nobody enjoys handing influence to a process that might produce a decision they believe is wrong. Yet it exposes a weakness in the way we sometimes talk about democracy. Do we support public participation because we believe people should have a fair opportunity to take part, or because we hope they will reach the “right” answer?
Imagine a citizens’ assembly examining a controversial issue. Members are selected to reflect the population, hear evidence from different sides and deliberate over several weekends. At the end, they recommend a policy that you strongly oppose.
Would you accept the process as legitimate?
You might challenge the evidence, the selection method or the way the question was framed. Those are reasonable concerns. A citizens’ assembly must be open to scrutiny. But if the process was fair, the evidence balanced and the deliberation genuine, should disagreement with the conclusion be enough to dismiss it?
This is where the distinction between process and outcome becomes crucial.
A democratic process cannot guarantee that everyone gets what they want. Elections don’t do that either. Their legitimacy rests partly on agreed rules: who can vote, how votes are counted and how power changes hands. A deliberative assembly needs similarly clear rules: how people are selected, what information they receive, who sets the agenda and what authority their recommendations carry.
The study is a useful warning against treating sortition as a cure-all. Random selection may broaden participation, but it cannot eliminate self-interest, disagreement or disappointment. Nor should it.
The more demanding test is whether people are prepared to accept a fair process when it produces an inconvenient result.
This question sits close to the heart of *The Answer*, Kizzi Nkwocha’s book about sortition and democratic reform.
Would you trust the judgement of a properly selected and informed citizens’ assembly if its recommendation went against your own position? If not, what would make you trust it?
Book: https://www.amazon.com/Answer-Sortition-Rebuild-Broken-Politics/dp/B0G6FRDMJ1/
#Democracy, #Sortition, #CitizensAssemblies, #PoliticalTrust, #PublicOpinion, #PoliticalReform, #DeliberativeDemocracy, #CivicEngagement, #Governance, #TheAnswer
Want more like this?
Get an occasional email when there’s something new worth reading. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
By subscribing you agree to receive occasional emails about new releases. Unsubscribe anytime by replying to any email.


