Expert ViewAdvice · Ask The Experts

The Problem With Random Selection Is That It Might Actually Be Fairer

Would you rather be governed by people who are exceptionally good at persuading voters, or…

Would you rather be governed by people who are exceptionally good at persuading voters, or by people who look much more like the population they serve?

The question sounds unfair. Persuasion is a legitimate democratic skill, and elections give citizens a way to remove leaders they dislike. But there is another issue hiding underneath: the people who seek political office are not necessarily a representative sample of the people who live with political decisions.

Candidates choose to enter politics. They may have the money, time, confidence, networks or personal ambition required to campaign. Many people who are knowledgeable, thoughtful or directly affected by policy never put themselves forward.

Random selection starts from a different premise.

A citizens’ assembly can invite a large number of people and select a smaller group by lot, using demographic criteria to make the final group broadly reflect the population. The intention isn’t to find the most charismatic citizens. It is to create a miniature version of the public.

This approach has a long history in democratic thinking, but it is also being developed in modern institutions. A 2026 overview from More Democracy describes permanent or recurring citizens’ assemblies in places including Paris, Rennes, Rouen and Marseille. In these models, randomly selected residents can deliberate on public questions and make recommendations to local authorities.

The word “random” can be misleading, though. A fair process is not simply pulling names out of a hat and hoping for the best.

If invitations go to thousands of people but only those with free time, confidence and a strong interest in politics respond, the final group may still be skewed. Good design therefore involves stratified selection, payment or compensation, childcare and accessibility support, and practical help that allows people with different circumstances to participate.

There is also a question of accountability. Elected representatives can be voted out. A randomly selected participant may serve for a limited period and then return to ordinary life. That can reduce career incentives, but it also means the assembly needs a clear mandate, transparent proceedings and a defined relationship with elected institutions.

The point is not that random selection makes people wise. It is that political ambition is not the only possible qualification for taking part in public decision-making.

And perhaps it is worth asking why we have become so accustomed to treating the ability to win an election as the main test of someone’s suitability to help govern.

This is a central argument in *The Answer*, Kizzi Nkwocha’s book on sortition and the possibility of rebuilding democratic institutions around ordinary citizens.

Would you regard a randomly selected group that reflects your community as more representative than a group of elected politicians — or does the absence of an election make its authority fundamentally weaker?

Book: https://www.amazon.com/Answer-Sortition-Rebuild-Broken-Politics/dp/B0G6FRDMJ1/

#Sortition, #Representation, #CitizensAssemblies, #Democracy, #PoliticalReform, #PublicVoice, #CivicParticipation, #Governance, #PoliticalEquality, #TheAnswer

Want more like this?

Get an occasional email when there’s something new worth reading. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

By subscribing you agree to receive occasional emails about new releases. Unsubscribe anytime by replying to any email.

About the author
Kizzi Nkwocha
More from Kizzi Nkwocha →
The Viewspaper Briefing, by email

The issues that matter, in your inbox each week.

The latest Briefing, the editor’s column and the week’s best arguments.

The newsletter launches shortly.